Between October and February there is simply not much light. A few things I have tried over the last three winters:

StockISOWhat I liked
Portra 400400Forgiving, nice skin tones, pushes to 800 fine
HP5 Plus400Cheap, classic grain, great pushed to 1600
CineStill 800T800Street lights at night, red halos are fun once

For most walks I end up with HP5 pushed one stop. Black and white also hides the fact that half of the city is grey slush anyway.